According to a news report today from the Associated Press, the enrollment numbers in Colorado are about half of what the state had projected as its “worst case scenario” for enrollment in its Exchange. The 6,001 Colorodoans who have enrolled thus far (and that is enrolled, not yet paid) is also way less than the 20,186 that had served as the midpoint projection for this time in the open enrollment season. Colorado officials apparently believed that 136,000 people would enroll by the end of 2014. Enrollment thus far has apparently been complicated, however, by a requirement that consumers seeking a subsidy on the exchange first find out if they qualify for Medicaid, which may require a 12-page application.
Three facts make the low Colorado numbers yet more troubling for those concerned either about a reduction in the number of uninsured individuals or about the prospects that those getting enrollment in the Exchanges for 2014 will shortly find themselves sucked into an adverse selection death spiral.
Second, it comes in a state where between 106,000 and 250,000 individual health insurance policies have been cancelled. I have an inquiry in but have not yet been able to find from published sources whether Colorado will permit insurers to reinstate those policies and under what conditions. [LATE BREAKING NEWS at 13:52 Houston time: Colorado insurance official says Colorado expects to announce a decision on this point later today or tomorrow (per email from Vincent Plymell, Communications Director at the Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies, who courteously responded to my inquiry)]
Third, Colorado already had 1,227 people enrolled in the Federal Pre-Existing Condition Insurance Plan (PCIP). One would think those people, who tend to have high medical expenses and are willing to pay full freight for insurance, would have been among the earliest to sign up under the Colorado exchange with the potential for subsidized rates. Thus, some of the 6,001 already enrolled may not represent a reduction in people without insurance to people with health insurance but merely a substitution from one federally created plan to another.